What does it mean to be conservative?

The modern ideal of conservatism arose as a rejection of Enlightenment principles and their instantiation in political revolution, particularly the French Revolution. Conservatives such as Burke and de Maistre defended the centrality of religion, family, land, and morality in bolstering society. Today, the word has lost much of its meaning as it’s largely become the name of the opposition party against liberal progressivism, but not all that distinct from it–almost progressivism light, embodying the same principles but in a more cautious manner. We lack true conservatives in politics who really work for local government and economics, promote education rooted in the formation of the person rather than pragmatism, and embody a principled moral leadership.

The conservative label also has been applied infelicitously within the Catholic Church. Rather than the political left/right divide that arose in the French Revolution between republicans and monarchists, it has come to represent alternative ways of interpreting the Second Vatican Council. Conservatives seek to preserve traditional expressions of doctrine and liturgy (whether Pre-Vatican II expressions or in continuity with them) and liberals seek greater accommodation to the culture and embrace progressive positions characterized as in line with the “Spirit” of Vatican II or a radical development of the tradition. When pigeonholed into this dichotomy, it can be difficult to characterize oneself as a conservative, because it will be reduced to a kind of ecclesial reaction (by nature negative). That may not always be a problem per se but it misses the deeper meaning of conservatism.

I would propose a more complete vision of Catholic conservatism, beginning with a deeper definition of conservatism itself. On the latter point, Russell Kirk provides a great starting point, laying out six general principles in his essay “Conservatism: A Succinct Definition.” My comments are in parentheses.

  • “First, conservatives generally believe that there exists a transcendent moral order, to which we ought to try to conform the ways of society.” (This means that we do not set our own terms but accept a standard above our own selves.)
  • “Second, conservatives uphold the principle of social continuity.” (Seeing social change as disruptive).
  • “Third, conservatives believe in what may be called the principle of prescription.” (Preserving acquired wisdom and the customs of ancestors).
  • “Fourth, conservatives are guided by their principle of prudence.” (Being cautious and deliberate in making decisions).
  • “Fifth, conservatives pay attention to the principle of variety.” (Not seeking the lowest common denominator or making people conform to one absolute or centralized standard).
  • “Sixth, conservatives are chastened by their principle of imperfectability.” (They are realistic, and perhaps pessimistic at times, due to their attention to human failure).

To these six principles proposed by Kirk, I would add two more of my own:

  • Seventh, conservatives seek to preserve timeless goods by cherishing beauty in the arts and architecture and preserving liberal education.
  • Eighth, they uphold the principle of subsidiarity by remaining rooted in the foundation of the family, the importance of self-sufficiency, and the priority of local community, economics, politics, and culture.

Drawing upon these principles, I would propose the following application for an articulation of a more robust Catholic conservatism:

  • Conservative Catholics preserve the priority of God’s revelation and its expression by the Church in her doctrine.
  • Conservative Catholics uphold the unbroken nature of tradition and seek to hand it on to the next generation.
  • Conservative Catholics are cautious in the face of proposed changes in the Church and society.
  • Conservative Catholics value the beautiful diversity within the Church of various cultures, intellectual traditions, and liturgical rites.
  • Conservative Catholics are attentive to how sin corrupts us within the Church and work for continual spiritual and moral renewal.
  • Conservative Catholics promote beautiful art, architecture, and music in the Church and seek to restore the Church’s tradition of teaching the liberal arts.
  • Conservative Catholics uphold the primary rights and duties of parents and seek to form strong community in the parish, confraternities, and other Catholic organizations to live out the faith in daily life.

To balance these principles, we should also articulate some vices of conservatives: Emphasizing self-reliance too heavily and not attending sufficiently to the needs of others; having a reactionary mindset; resisting good and necessary change; being too idealistic; giving into a power struggle for control within a paradigm set up by progressives (which does not work); and falling into cynicism or even despair in the face of what appears to be unstoppable change. To overcome the vices of conservatives we could also add the following principles to push conservatives beyond narrow confines:

  • Conservative Catholics should work harder to uphold the dignity of all human beings, especially those marginalized and vulnerable in society.
  • Conservative Catholics should grow in hope by trusting in God’s providential care for the Church and human history.
  • Conservative Catholics should give others, including Church leaders and those with whom they disagree, more understanding, support, and prayer.

Conservative Catholics work to preserve and uphold genuine and necessary goods within the life of the Church and society. In addition, they can break out of the confines of a conservative label, and the vices that follow it, by showing greater charity and hope to others.

I hope these principles provide a more robust and detailed articulation of the values and aspirations of Catholics who seek to remain rooted in tradition and to live according to timeless truths.


5 Comments

Bill M · January 28, 2023 at 9:26 pm

Nice job Jared. A reasonable well thought out piece. Dare I say original. Really needs a more detailed response. Thanks for beginning a solid dialogue!

Bill Mazzella · January 29, 2023 at 11:25 am

“Conservative Catholics preserve the priority of God’s revelation and its expression by the Church in her doctrine.
Conservative Catholics uphold the unbroken nature of tradition and seek to hand it on to the next generation.
Conservative Catholics are cautious in the face of proposed changes in the Church and society.”

I am not sure you modify the above with your additions. It might be important to note that progressives in the church can really agree with the above. The devil, as usual, is in the details. Perhaps the first area to address are the Fathers of the Church. It always intrigued me that leaders who came four centuries after the Apostles can be called: “The Fathers of the Church.” What does that say about the leaders who led in the first three plus centuries? Are they the Fathers of the “Constantine” Church? You know the guy who paraded the head of the Emperors he defeated through the streets of the Empire? Then the obsequious Eusebius canonized him with the myth of “In hoc signo vinces.” In this sign you will conquer! What could be further from the truth? And then Augustine, who is indisputably the spokesman for the Western Church? Who first proposed killing other Chrustuans! And introduced Manichaeism to the Body of Christ. And Athanasius who is the indisputable leader of the Eastern Church? Who paraded up and down Persia begging the sons of Constantine to restore him as the head of the Eastern Church.
Should you not address these?

R Berger · September 19, 2023 at 11:25 am

After decades of trying to be Catholic in all spheres, including political and economic, I must say I find Harry V Jaffa the best guide. And Lincoln is the master of natural law and the “civil religion’ that makes the US workable.
I don’t disagree with this but I find most writing to be useless. Take the ‘common good’ . With over 100 million citizens killed by their own government in the 20th Century you wouild think that the emphasis on the individual would be supreme.
Pacem in Terris , Pope John XXIII is my guide on this
“Responsibilities of the Public Authority, and Rights and Duties of Individuals

60. It is generally accepted today that the common good is best safeguarded when personal rights and duties are guaranteed. The chief concern of civil authorities must therefore be to ensure that these rights are recognized, respected, co-ordinated, defended and promoted, and that each individual is enabled to perform his duties more easily. For “to safeguard the inviolable rights of the human person, and to facilitate the performance of his duties, is the principal duty of every public authority.”

MONDAY EDITION – Big Pulpit · January 30, 2023 at 5:01 am

[…] Guns Don’t Kill People . . . People Kill People – Gene Van Son at Catholic Stand Seeking Genuine Catholic Conservatism – R. Jared Staudt, Ph.D., at Building Catholic Culture The ‘Christian Nationalism’ […]

Seeking Genuine Catholic Conservatism – Building Catholic Culture – The Faith Herald · January 30, 2023 at 2:45 pm

[…] Open the full article on the buildingcatholicculture.com site […]

Leave a Reply