“Jesus” is the Greek version of the name Joshua. In many ways his ministry shows him to be a new Moses, offering bread from heaven, giving a new commandment, and instituting a new Passover. The goal of the Exodus was to enter the Promised Land to live in covenant with God. Jesus, as the new Joshua, conquers God’s enemies and destroys death, opening up the passage to the true, eternal promised land of heaven. The conquest, therefore, speaks to the Easter season of opening up God’s promises for us.
Hearkening back to the conquest, however, raises thorny theological questions. Many people have argued that the conquest of Canaan demonstrates that God is unjust because he ordered the eradication of entire peoples. There is no doubt that this constitutes a truly difficult question for many people. In order to understand, we cannot simply approach it with a material perspective or one that treats the actions of God and man as equivalent. It is true that human beings cannot simply execute this kind of judgment on a group of people. But, if we believe in the reality of sin and just judgment of God, then there is a way to make sense of the conquest. I’d like to offer some broader thoughts to put things into perspective.
- Death caused by sin. The Bible makes clear that death was not part of God’s original plan for humanity. It enters into human life through sin. God is not the author of human death, and it falls to humanity as a punishment for sin. Death follows sin and constitutes the punishment that everyone must face at one time or another, a time known only by God.
- Consequences of original sin. The Church teaches that all people are born into a state of original sin. This means that we are not born with the grace God originally intended for all people, which we need to be in communion with him and go to heaven. We are born in a fallen state, subject to death. We cannot, therefore, say that anyone is innocent before God and not deserving of death. God is not unjust to will the death of any person at any time.
- Sin is much worse than death. Our reactions to the conquest reflect the modern perspective that health and safety are more important than the state of the soul. The saints have said that one venial sin is worse than the destruction of the entire physical universe because it offends God. We have our priorities wrong in evaluating the story, focusing more on physical death than the state of rebellion of the Canaanites against their Creator.
- God as judge. Human beings cannot take innocent human life, but God is the Lord of life and death. God revealed to the Israelites at Mt. Sinai that they should not kill. We seem to have a contradiction at first. But, we also see that God instituted capital punishment, reflecting an early quote from Genesis: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed; for God made man in his own image.” This shows us that God can institute the taking of human life as a means of judgment, which he executes through the instrumentality of human beings.
- Corporate punishment plays an important role in the conquest. While it is true that only individuals are directly responsible for sins that are committed, there is a social dimension of sin that alters the character of communities. Even in the case of individual families, if a father uses his home as a place of drug trafficking, for instance, the entire family is drawn into the harm of being exposed to visits from dangerous accomplices and potential retribution against its activities. Children often bear the consequences of the choices of parents, and children born into particular nations are drawn into their ways of thinking and living. When these are directed in unholy and evil ways, everyone in the culture, personally culpable or not, is part of a collective body with its own moral state and collective aims. It is simply a fact of the human race as a social body that we experience the consequences of others within our communities, especially when they are overriding or guiding decisions and habits.
- Warfare as punishment. We see that God uses warfare as one means of executing his judgment upon humanity. Beyond the conquest, you can see this with the Philistines punishing Israel for idolatry, and the conquest of the Assyrians and Babylonians both being presented as the punishment of God for infidelity. The Persians deliver the Jews from the Exile, having brought punishment on the Babylonians, as foreordained by God. You can see a modern example in the message of Our Lady of Fatima to the three children during World War I: “The war is going to end; but if people do not cease offending God, a worse one will break out during the pontificate of Pius XI. When you see a night illumined by an unknown light, know that this is the great sign given you by God that he is about to punish the world for its crimes, by means of war, famine, and persecutions of the Church and of the Holy Father.”
- Particular timing related to sin. God makes it clear that the timing of the conquest is significant. Abraham cannot take possession of the land yet because “the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet complete” (Genesis 15:16). This will not happen until his descendants “shall come back here in the fourth generation.” This shows the justice of God, providentially aligning the gift of the land to a time when it would be rightfully taken from a people whose sin shall have reached a point that demands punitive action.
- Purification of spiritually polluted land. Israel is given a spiritual mission to purify the land from sin and re-order it to God. The Canaanites had polluted the land itself through what God calls “abominable practices.” Deuteronomy 19 gives us a list: “There shall not be found among you any one who burns his son or his daughter as an offering, any one who practices divination, a soothsayer, or an augur, or a sorcerer, or a charmer, or a medium, or a wizard, or a necromancer. For whoever does these things is an abomination to the Lord” (vv 10-12). By living according to the Lord’s will and becoming holy, Israel can restore the land to its integrity as a temple for the Lord. But, as we know, they would eventually suffer the same fate of losing the land at the hands of the Assyrians (northern tribes) and Babylonians (southern tribes). Leviticus 18 offers a warning: “Do not defile yourselves by any of these things [relating to sexual immorality], for by all these the nations I am casting out before you defiled themselves; and the land became defiled, so that I punished its iniquity, and the land vomited out its inhabitants. But you shall keep my statutes and my ordinances and do none of these abominations, either the native or the stranger who sojourns among you (for all of these abominations the men of the land did, who were before you, so that the land became defiled); lest the land vomit you out, when you defile it, as it vomited out the nation that was before you (vv. 24–28).” This spiritual cleansing mission helps us to understand the consequences of sin and the need to address them.
- Repentance. Someone might object, why didn’t God give people a chance to repent? For one, he gave them centuries, but instead their sin grew to a fullness of inquiry. Two, we do see instances of people being saved. The most prominent example is Rahab, who helps the Israelite spies in Jericho and who becomes an ancestor of David (and therefore of Our Lord). Though they employed deceits, the Gibeonites are spared and become servants of the altar, helping to prepare for sacrifice. And, after the conquest, we have the example of Ruth, the Moabite, who also becomes an ancestor of David and Jesus. People who genuinely repent and turn to God for mercy are given mercy. The bigger question may be, why didn’t more of the Canaanites do this?
- Small garrison cities. There is also an issue of scale at play. When we hear that Canaanite cities were burned, we may imagine large metropolises. However, we are speaking of small military strongholds with little regular population. They were more like garissons, and some of the surrounding population may have sought refuge there during the invasion. In addition, it was a regular practice of warfare to treat the entire population of a walled city that refused to capitulate as combatants. (Not that this is a good practice, but it sheds light on the historical context.)
- Demonic warfare. Fr. Stephen De Young helps us to see an additional layer of demonic warfare at play in the text. The Israelites are directed to conquer and eradicate the Anakim, “giant” tribes that were specifically dedicated to demons. Their rulers were conceived ritually, making them the children of demonic gods, who then exercised a tyranny over them. This is why they sacrificed their children and engaged in sexual immorality. The ban on destroying all their people and goods had to do with the fact that they were under a demonic curse, which had tainted the land and all within it spiritually. Other tribes are dispossessed of the land but not eradicated.
- A warning. Finally, there is a strong allegorical meaning to the text, showing us that our own Exodus into the Promised Land must have the same uncompromising battle against sin and evil in our lives. Like other biblical events, the allegorical meaning is rooted in the literal and historical reality of the events themselves. St. Paul tells us about the Israelites in the desert, “Now these things happened to them as a warning, but they were written down for our instruction, upon whom the end of the ages has come” (2 Cor 10:11). Sin is a matter of life and death, and we need to take the battle against it much more seriously.
- God’s mercy. The spiritual cleansing of the conquest is not an example of a capricious and vengeful God. Rather, God puts a limit to our sin and intervenes to stop it when it exceeds normal bounds. This should help us to realize that suffering and even death themselves are not ultimately punishments but are a call to repentance. When we experience suffering, we are meant to turn to the Lord for mercy, and his mercy knows no bounds. Christ died for all, to redeem their suffering and sin, and to pour out his saving mercy to all the nations.
0 Comments